UPDATE: Helped (see comments). Thanks Susan! Though Time Out NY totally cheated, as the "A" in question seems to be from a chain that's not even in Manhattan.
Above is a section of the cover of last week's Time Out New York. My typography-savvy daughters and I pretty quickly named which logo each letter came from... except for that second "A".
It's totally driving us nuts. It's got to be something really obvious, but we've spent a week now thinking and arguing and scoping signage all over town, and have come up empty.
Please release us from our torment, and, if you know, let us know, in the comments.
Thank you very VERY much.